Lawyers For Assailant in Germantown Academy Lawsuit Regarding Athlete-on-Athlete Abuse Threaten Muchnick a Second Time

USA Track & Field CEO Max Siegel Sprints to Front of Pack in Multiple Personal Income Streams With Conflicts of Interest
August 16, 2016
UC Berkeley Chancellor Dirks, Who Presided Over Cover-Up of Football Player Ted Agu’s Death, to Resign in 2017
August 17, 2016
USA Track & Field CEO Max Siegel Sprints to Front of Pack in Multiple Personal Income Streams With Conflicts of Interest
August 16, 2016
UC Berkeley Chancellor Dirks, Who Presided Over Cover-Up of Football Player Ted Agu’s Death, to Resign in 2017
August 17, 2016

Complete headline links to our series on Dick Shoulberg and Germantown Academy are at

Here is the text of a letter sent to Concussion Inc. via email at 12:19 p.m. PDT on Thursday, August 11, by attorney Vanessa M. McGill of the McGill-Lewis law firm:




August 12, 2016

Dear Mr. Muchnick:


I am writing on behalf of Mr. Alex Lebed about whom you have published false, destructive and defamatory statements. As you are certainly aware, it is unlawful to engage in defamation of another’s character and reputation. Your defamatory statements can be found at the following link:

Your article misstates facts and circumstances. Alex has never been suspended from USA Swimming, any school or any club. Alex never swam “unaffiliated” at the NSCA championships; rather, Alex swam with a personal swim coach, allowing him to qualify to represent the United States at the Ireland Open Swim Championships in 2014.

Alex has devoted ample time and efforts defending himself and his reputation, which resulted in the expungement of the arrest referenced in your articles. Mind you, Alex was a minor at the time. It is quite unfair that even though the judicial system saw fit to remove traces of the juvenile arrest from his record that this online record remains in existence, further condemning Alex.

Alex is an honest student and athlete who has worked tirelessly to cultivate and maintain a positive reputation in the community. The publication of your article has and will continue to damage his reputation in that very same community. In the interest of protecting and preserving his livelihood and his reputation, Alex hereby demands that the article be removed in its entirety. Please provide us with prompt written assurance within seven (7) days that you will remove the article referenced above.


Vanessa M. McGill


Here is our response via email at 1:00 p.m. PDT the same day:



From: Irvin Muchnick

To: Vanessa M. McGill

Sent: Friday, August 12, 2016 1:00 PM



Ms. McGill:

I received your letter.

I do not contemplate taking down the post to which you and your client take exception.

I am happy, in the alternative, to do one of two things:

1 – Republish the article, and include your specific points of dispute.

2 – Publish an entirely new post containing the full text of your letter.


Irvin Muchnick


Here is the disputed March 14 article:

University of Florida’s Alex Lebed Swam ‘Unaffiliated’ in 2014 National Meet After Getting Thrown Out of Germantown Academy – So Much For His Suspension by USA Swimming

Published March 14th, 2016

Complete headline links to our series on the abuse scandals at Dick Shoulberg’s Germantown Academy swimming program are at

by Irvin Muchnick

We already know that Alex Lebed, the University of Florida freshman swimmer who is about to represent the Gators in the upcoming National Collegiate Athletic Association championships, is the “A.L.” in the civil lawsuit against the Germantown Academy, near Philadelphia, by fellow ex-Dick Shoulberg swimmer “John Doe.” And that after Germantown finally threw out Lebed, USA Swimming suspended him.

The term of the suspension was tricky, however, and further points to how our Olympic governing body enables the bad behavior of certain individuals while shoving safety principles way down the list of priorities.

Meet records show that Lebed swam “unaffiliated” in the March 2014 National Swimming Club Association (NSCA) junior short-course championships in Orlando.

So when was his “90-day suspension” from USA Swimming? Most likely April-May-June 2014.

It’s useless asking the so-called Safe Sport department at Colorado Springs headquarters; the people there are already documented as doctoring the record of the suspension of dirty old man California coach Bill Jewell, and they’ve been shown time and again to enable the well-connected. They also don’t respond to Concussion Inc.’s inquiries, presumably because, unlike those of major media outlets, ours contain substance instead of puffery.

Seven months after his NSCA appearance – and after attaining the legally adult age of 18 – Lebed was arrested again in Pennsylvania for disorderly conduct.

Next week, Lebed swims the 400 individual medley for Florida in the NCAA’s.

The week after that, his lawyer will be asking the Montgomery County Court of Common Pleas to expunge his 2014 arrest record.



Exclusive: University of Florida Coach Gregg Troy Was Investigated For a 2013 Complaint to the Athletic Department by a Female Swimmer

Published March 9th, 2016


See It Now – Germantown Academy Lawsuit Complaint With Allegations of Horrid Abuse at Swim Legend Dick Shoulberg’s Program

Published February 13th, 2016


Named Assailant in Germantown Academy Swim Abuse Lawsuit Is Part of Coach Dick Shoulberg’s Historical Pipeline to Gregg Troy at the University of Florida

Published February 24th, 2016


University of Florida Responds to Concussion Inc.’s Report on Former Germantown (Dick Shoulberg), Now Gators (Gregg Troy) Swimmer

Published February 25th, 2016


‘A.L.,’ the Abusive Swimmer at Dick Shoulberg’s Germantown Academy Program, Seeks Expungement of His Criminal Record

Published February 26th, 2016


More Info on Adult Arrest of ‘A.L’ – Dick Shoulberg’s Germantown Academy Swimmer Who Had Been Accused of Athlete-on-Athlete Abuse

Published March 8th, 2016


University of Florida, Like Yale, Remains Mum on Championship Athlete With Hovering Misconduct Allegations

Published March 11th, 2016

Comments are closed.

Concussion Inc. - Author Irvin Muchnick