NFL Lawyer to No Comment on Account of Dave Duerson Absence From Retirement Board Meeting

Matt Chaney With an Early-Season National Roundup of Football Deaths
September 15, 2011
Sports Fans Coalition: NFL Must Reconsider Player Disability Claims That Were ‘Swept Aside’
September 15, 2011

Alex Marvez, senior pro football writer for, reports that a federal judge in Maryland has set a February 27, 2012, trial date in retired National Football League player Andrew Stewart’s lawsuit against the Bert Bell / Pete Rozelle NFL Retirement Plan. See

Marvez’s story today notes that, as this blog has reported – and in contrast to the strong suggestion of the collective NFL statements to him for last month’s coverage of the Stewart case – “Dave Duerson didn’t vote upon Stewart’s claim as initially believed. Duerson – a star NFL safety who committed suicide in February — was one of the NFL Players Association’s three trustee appointees on the board. The other three were appointed by the NFL.”

This trial, the story says, “could reveal some of the NFL’s retirement program’s secretive inner workings.”

Marvez says a proxy “is believed” to have taken Duerson’s spot at the August 18, 2010, meeting of the board in Boston, where Stewart’s disability claim was reviewed and unanimously rejected. From my reporting, I think it’s pretty clear that that proxy was Andre Collins.

NFL lawyer Douglas Ell “declined comment to”

Interestingly, Ell has filed a motion to remand the case to re-review by the NFL board. I support some kind of re-review of all Duerson-tainted cases. Stewart’s attorney, Michael Rosenthal, however, opposes the motion – apparently because he feels, no doubt correctly, that at this point his client would get a fairer shake in a court of law than through a process now so despised and distrusted by many in the NFL retiree community.


Irv Muchnick





Duerson Apparently Did Not Review Andrew Stewart NFL Disability Claim


Why Wasn’t Dave Duerson at the August 2010 NFL Disability Review Board Hearing?


Dave Duerson Was in Good Spirits at August 2010 NFL Retirement Board Meeting. OR Duerson Missed That Meeting. Which Is It?


NFL Player Care Executive Director Changes Story — Confirms That Dave Duerson Was Not at August 2010 Retirement Board Meeting


Sports Fans Coalition: NFL Must Reconsider Player Disability Claims That Were ‘Swept Aside’


Complete Links to Dave Duerson Coverage at

Comments are closed.

Concussion Inc. - Author Irvin Muchnick