Sports Illustrated Writer Promises ‘Update’ of Incorrect August Story About Braeden Bradforth Death That Echoed Garden City Community College Football Coach’s Spin That the Cause Was a Blood Clot, Rather Than Exertional Heat Stroke

Echoes of Louisville High School Football Coach’s Reckless Homicide Prosecution in Exertional Heat Stroke Death Are Evident in Emerging Details About Coach Jeff Sims With Braeden Bradforth at Garden City Community College in Kansas
December 11, 2018
Now That Sports Illustrated Is Committed to ‘Updating Accordingly’ Its Erroneous Coach Jeff Sims-Fed Spin on the Cause of Braeden Bradforth’s Death, When Will the Magazine Decide to Do a, Like, Accountable Story About It?
December 14, 2018

by Irvin Muchnick


Charlotte Carroll, author of the inaccurate August story at — online arm of Sports Illustrated — about the conditioning drill death of Garden City Community College football player Braeden Bradforth, says she will “update” the information there on cause of death.

Relying only on a misleading and self-serving quote from head coach Jeff Sims, who has moved on to Missouri Southern State University, Carroll had left the impression that Bradforth died of a blood clot.

The autopsy two weeks ago confirmed that it was actually exertional heat stroke. In a contemporaneous emergency medical services report obtained this week by Concussion Inc., paramedics say Bradforth was found drenched in water, and the Garden City CC coaching staff told them that they had the stricken, moaning, unresponsive 19-year-old soaked with a hose prior to the 911 call.

Writer Carroll told Jill Greene, the lawyer for Bradforth’s mother Joanne Atkins-Ingram, that her failure to respond earlier to multiple messages was due to her being on vacation. “I’ll update our original story accordingly,” Carroll said in an email.

The Carroll-to-Greene email was transmitted at 3:05 p.m. Eastern time. Internet time stamps show that this was certainly less than an hour, and possibly as few as three minutes, after I tweeted the following:


Irvin Muchnick@irvmuch

Sports Illustrated (@SInow) doesn’t seem to want to explain why it won’t bother to help the truth catch up with the lie by Garden City Community College football coach Jeff Sims, about the cause of conditioning death of Braeden Bradforth, as transcribed in SI’s August coverage.

Later today at  we’ll review the outdated and erroneous record @SInow created of the cause of Garden City CC football player Braeden Bradforth’s August 1 conditioning death. It was exertional heat stroke, not coach Jeff Sims’ promoted “blood clot.”


(Sports Illustrated’s managing editor, Chris Stone, and the Time Inc. media relations department, along with Carroll, did not respond to our two emailed queries over the last 36 hours. Wherever Stone is, he does not seem to be on vacation: his own Twitter feed shows him sounding off on other subjects.)

SI’s evident insouciance regarding coverage of a mere death constitutes less than sterling journalistic practice. Let me also say that more is in order here than a buried “update”; what’s needed is a fresh and engaged new story with more prominent play than the original bad one. But I’m glad Carroll and SI are taking at least a baby step toward correcting the public record.



Comments are closed.

Concussion Inc. - Author Irvin Muchnick